On the afternoon of May 1, Laura Klock was leading a group of school kids through Farm Life Creamery when she heard sirens. Then an employee ran in to say the barn was on fire. Klock asked which barn. The answer was the one at the farm.
That was the dairy barn belonging to Gary and Amy Blase, parents of Klock's business partner and co-owner Chad Blase. It sits about three miles west of the creamery outlet at 41053 265th St., and its cows supply the milk behind Farm Life's cheese and bottled milk. Five months later, the Ethan farm gate is closed for the season. The creamery's own site says production continues. Part of the reason is a relationship that started before anything burned. Farm Life had been sharing its equipment with a neighboring dairy, and after the fire that dairy helped milk the Blase cows.
What burned, and what didn't
The Mitchell Republic reported the losses: the whole milking room, the robotic milkers, a lawnmower and tools, the dairy records and computers, and several awards and trophies. No cows were lost, and only property was damaged.
Dairy Star covered the fire in more detail on May 23. Gary Blase had just finished scraping alleys and parked his skid steer in the heated shop attached to the milk barn. He started feeding cows, and within minutes a cloud of smoke was rising over the shop. The family suspects the fire started in the skid steer, possibly from hay or debris near the engine. Dakota News Now described the cause more firmly, as a malfunctioning skid steer that sparked. As of the latest reporting, the family's own account is still a suspicion, not a finding.
The cows were at the far end of the barn from where the fire started, so the family moved them to a north pasture with the wind carrying the smoke away. An old red barn full of straw stood 20 feet from the flames and ended up with only a small hole burned through it. Some losses can't be replaced. Decades of show banners, awards and every breeding and herd record went with the building. The family had kept the records both in notebooks and on a computer, and both were in the barn.
"We always thought if the computer ever went down, at least we had handwritten records. We just never thought about a fire." Gary Blase, to Dairy Star
The help had already been running the other way
After the fire, the herd needed somewhere to be milked. The Mitchell Republic reported that Scheetz Mercantile, a family-run micro-dairy near Mount Vernon, and Dave Ripp stepped in to handle the milking for the Blase herd. Dairy Star reported that the 25 milk cows were moved to two neighbors' dairy farms for temporary housing and milking. The Mitchell Republic put the herd at about 30 head.
Scheetz Mercantile had already been depending on Farm Life before the fire. In December 2025, the Mitchell Republic covered Scheetz's launch of what it called South Dakota's first commercially made cup-set, French-style creamline yogurt. It's made from nonhomogenized milk using Farm Life's equipment. That same article listed Farm Life Creamery in Ethan as one of the places selling the yogurt, alongside grocery stores in Parkston and Armour and Makers Exchange in Tea.
So the Mount Vernon dairy that took in the Blase cows in May had been making its yogurt on Farm Life's equipment and selling it on Farm Life's shelves for months. When the fire hit, the relationship flipped direction. It was already in place.
The Mitchell Republic said the borrowed milking was reducing the impact on the Ethan outlet and on Farm Life's second location at County Fair in Mitchell, keeping both mostly stocked. Dakota News Now reported that neighbors also brought food and offered help. Farm Life's homepage also says its cheese is handcrafted with Grade A milk from local South Dakota dairy farms, so its milk supply was never meant to depend on a single barn.
Why the gate is closed but the bottles keep coming
Farm Life calls itself South Dakota's only small, licensed Grade A milk bottling plant. Without that license, the creamery couldn't bottle milk at all. The milk can come from neighboring herds, but the bottling, the cheese making and the ice cream all depend on the creamery's own plant and staff. The things that had to stop were the parts that bring visitors onto the farm.
The current notice on the site is direct. The Ethan farm and creamery is closed to visitors for the fall and winter season. Production continues, but there are no public visits, tours, mini-golf, field trips or events, and the owners thank customers for giving them space to work, plan and prepare for next season. That closure covers the 18-hole mini-golf course set in the farm's shelterbelt.
The site still has an older Honor Shop page describing a stocked entryway fridge that is "always open" for cash, check or Venmo. That page conflicts with the closure notice, and the site doesn't say which one applies right now. Until the creamery posts an update, plan to buy in Mitchell rather than driving out to 265th St.
Where Farm Life is selling this fall
| Location | When | What's there |
|---|---|---|
| County Fair Food Store, 1305 Havens, Mitchell | 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., seven days a week | Bottled milk, handcrafted cheese, ice cream, espresso and coffee, chai, matcha, smoothies, cones, shakes, floats, grab-and-go items |
| Falls Park Farmers Market, Sioux Falls | Saturdays 8 a.m. to 1 p.m., May through October | Milk, cheese and ice cream |
| Ethan farm, 41053 265th St. | Closed to visitors for fall and winter | No tours, mini-golf, field trips or events |
The Mitchell counter is the easiest stop for anyone in Ethan. It's open 12 hours a day, every day, and it serves coffee, so it works more like a café than a cheese case. The Falls Park market runs only through October, so a few Saturdays are left. Farm Life says its products also sell at "select local retailers" but doesn't name them on its current site, and it takes cheese tray and gift box orders online or in store. The product list includes fresh cheddar cheese curds and whole milk. All of the milk is nonhomogenized, so the cream rises to the top, and the creamery's advice is to shake it before pouring.
CheeseFest went on, and doubled as a fundraiser
The third annual CheeseFest was scheduled for Sunday, June 14, about six weeks after the fire. It was billed with a local cheese cook-off and public samples from 1 to 3 p.m. KELO reported that Farm Life planned the event partly as a fundraiser. The creamery's homepage now has a video titled "CheeseFest at Farm Life Creamery 2026," which is the clearest sign it went ahead. We didn't find any outside coverage of the event itself.
A smaller barn, with no date yet
The more telling number in the Dairy Star story is the herd size from a few years ago. The Blases had already downsized before May. Asked how the fire might have gone earlier, Gary put it plainly:
"If this had happened a couple of years ago, we probably would've had 220 cows locked in the barn."
Before the fire, the herd was down to about 25 cows, small enough that two neighbors could take them in on short notice. A 220-cow herd would have been much harder to place, and it's the smaller farm that made the recovery possible.
Gary is 73. He told Dairy Star he once thought a disaster like this might mean retirement, but the farm's next generation has changed that. The goal is to rebuild something smaller, with room for maybe 40 or 50 cows and another milking robot. The farm was an early adopter of robotic milking in South Dakota. The family valued the robots because they made it possible to keep up with the creamery, farmers markets and delivery routes at the same time.
As of the May 23 Dairy Star report, the family was still working through difficult decisions while focusing on cleanup, cow care and keeping the creamery running. We found no later report of construction starting, no rebuild timeline and no confirmed 2027 schedule for tours, mini-golf or CheeseFest. For now, the closest open Farm Life location is the counter inside County Fair Food Store in Mitchell.
At Mitchell Realty LLC, our brokers have handled farmsteads, acreage and outbuildings around Ethan for years. When a rebuild on a working dairy raises questions about land, access or what a property can support, reach out to a local expert who already knows the roads out past 265th St.