A neutral-sided single-story home with an attached two-car garage, deep dormant lawn, oak tree and clear concrete entry walk beneath an overcast autumn sky.

Davison County Can Cut Homeowners' Property Taxes With a Sales Tax. Who Would Pay for It?

Who pays when a county lowers property taxes on homes? In most of South Dakota, mostly the same people who own the homes. They pay a bit more at the register and get a bit back on the tax bill. Davison County may work differently, and the reason is the traffic that comes through Mitchell every day.

At a public forum on Sept. 22, 2026, at the Davison County Fairgrounds, South Dakota Department of Revenue Secretary Michael Houdyshell projected that an optional 0.5% county sales tax would bring in nearly $4.5 million a year in Davison County. The Mitchell Republic reported that the county government's share of owner-occupied property taxes currently comes to $4.14 million. On those projections, the sales tax would bring in more than the county now collects from owner-occupied homes. That makes Davison one of 36 South Dakota counties where Department of Revenue data shows the projected tax exceeding that share.

Why the Math Works Here and Not Everywhere

The tax is allowed under Senate Bill 96, passed during the 2026 legislative session. It lets a county commission adopt a gross receipts tax of up to one-half of 1% by ordinance. The money goes into a property tax reduction fund. In Davison County, that fund would reduce only the county portion of owner-occupied property tax bills, according to Mitchell Now. School district and city levies would be unaffected.

The county's case depends on where the sales tax would come from. Commission Chairman Randy Reider explained the difference to the Mitchell Republic ahead of the forum:

"When you look at the 46 counties that are quite rural and don't have much commerce, it's just like you're taxing yourself. There might not be much benefit. But if you're a county with an incredible amount of tourism or you're a hub where everybody comes for buying goods and spend money or to have professional services, you could have a lot of outside dollars to tax."

That same report cited a 2025 report to the South Dakota Department of Tourism ranking Davison County seventh of the state's 66 counties in direct visitor spending, at $122 million. Visitors, regional shoppers and people coming in for professional services would all pay the half-cent. The credit would target owner-occupied property in Davison County.

Inside the Credit and Outside It

The projection works because the cost is spread across everyone who shops in the county, and that same spread is what commissioners find hard to weigh. Reider told the Mitchell Republic that roughly 40% of the houses in Mitchell are rented, and those households would not benefit from the reduction fund. At the forum he said he had first opposed the plan because of the added burden on renters, but now hears "legitimate arguments on both sides." Commissioner John Claggett, the board's longest-serving member, said he supports the plan: "I would hope that we can pass that and make it happen."

Among owner-occupants, the dollar savings would not be equal. The Mitchell Republic reported that relief is applied as a uniform percentage credit, so owners of more expensive homes get larger dollar cuts than owners of modest homes. The figure most often quoted, $1,078 in savings on a $325,000 home, or 23%, comes from an example by Gov. Larry Rhoden's office. It is not a Davison County calculation.

The Calendar Is Longer Than It Looks

The timeline depends on the commission's decision and how the credit is applied. The sequence:

  1. No vote is scheduled. The Sept. 22 forum was informational, and Reider said the proposal "could be voted on right now or it could be a year from now." The county's Oct. 27, 2026 minutes and its Nov. 5 agenda do not list SB 96 business.
  2. Any ordinance could go to voters. An ordinance can be referred or challenged by an initiated petition.
  3. Collection could start July 1, 2027, at the earliest. That limit comes from state deadlines and notice periods.
  4. The credit could lag behind collection. The county could wait until it has collected the money, which would affect 2028 tax bills at the earliest. It could also apply the credit based on estimated revenue, which would require tax vendor systems to be ready for the 2027 tax year.

The state rate changes on the same date. The Department of Revenue's current rate table shows the 4.2% state rate running through June 30, 2027, which puts the return to 4.5% on July 1, 2027. State leaders plan to use that increase to reduce homeowner property taxes statewide. The related homeowner property tax reduction fund was created by Senate Bill 245. Mitchell's ordinary combined rate is currently 6.2%: the 4.2% state rate plus the city's 2.0% general municipal rate, according to the Department of Revenue's July 2026 municipal tax guide. If both changes happened, that ordinary rate would rise to 7.0%.

What Other Counties Decided

Davison County is deciding after several other counties have already acted, and they did not all decide the same way. As of South Dakota Searchlight's Oct. 7 report, Custer, Fall River, Lawrence, Lincoln, Meade and Pennington counties had adopted half-percent taxes without a public vote, with collection scheduled to begin in January.

The two counties that voted on Nov. 3 turned it down. According to unofficial results reported by South Dakota Searchlight, 56% of Brown County voters and 60% of Codington County voters opposed the tax. Shelly Alvine, who helped lead the Codington petition drive, told Searchlight that renters "wouldn't have benefited from lower property taxes while paying higher sales taxes." Gov. Rhoden said in a statement that "people in different counties will make different choices." Clay and Charles Mix counties hold special elections on their ordinances on Nov. 17.

Renters raised the same objection in Brown and Codington that Reider raised in Mitchell. What sets Davison County apart is the revenue side. Rural counties would mostly be taxing their own residents, while Davison would collect a meaningful share from visitors and regional shoppers.

A Note From the Forum

At the forum, retired Mitchell businessman Roger Musick noted that fewer than 150 homeowners use the senior assessment freeze. He estimated about 700 Davison County homeowners fall under its income limits.

Quick Answers

Has Davison County adopted the half-cent sales tax? No. The Sept. 22 forum ended without action, and the Oct. 27 minutes and Nov. 5 agenda do not include it.

Which portion of property tax bills would the fund offset? As described by the county, the fund would offset only the county portion of owner-occupied bills.

Could voters overturn it? An ordinance can be referred to a public vote or challenged by an initiated petition, which is how Codington County's ordinance reached the Nov. 3 ballot.

The brokers at Mitchell Realty LLC follow these commission meetings closely. Contact a Local Expert.

Work With Us

With unparalleled industry knowledge, experience, and local expertise, we're the Mitchell Real Estate experts you've been looking for. Whether you're buying or selling, we can help you get the best deal.

Follow Us on Instagram