Warmly lit adjoining brick storefronts beside a quiet downtown sidewalk with a green bench and scattered late-autumn leaves.

What's Replacing the Back 40 on Mitchell's Main Street

Before 511 N. Main St. was the Back 40 Taphouse Grill, it was the Moonlight Bar and Lounge. It was also the Jackpot Gamblin' bar, and at different times it held an old-time photography studio, a jewelry shop and a baseball card shop. Over the decades the building kept getting expanded and modified, and the Mitchell Republic reports that local contractors now consider it a loss because of all those changes.

That history explains the new plan. Israel Espinosa and his son Josh plan to tear the building down and put up a multi-story building around an open courtyard. It would have a row of storefronts, a market space in the middle and a scratch-kitchen restaurant on the second floor. The target opening is spring 2028. For most of its life this property held several small businesses at once, and the new plan returns it to that.

From One Restaurant to a Block of Storefronts

When the plan first became public in August, it was simpler. The Mitchell Republic reported on Aug. 18, 2026 that the building would be torn down and replaced with a two-story building: a restaurant with a full-service bar serving breakfast, lunch and dinner upstairs, and retail space on the ground floor. At that point Josh Espinosa described it to the City Council as a "multi commercial retail space to allow other businesses and bring some traction to downtown city of Mitchell."

According to the Mitchell Republic's Nov. 11 report, the family first thought about building one more restaurant on the property. They then widened the concept so the site could hold several businesses. Josh Espinosa told the paper this will be his father's last project, and he wants to get the layout right.

The courtyard is new territory for the family. Israel Espinosa's restaurants in Mitchell include Corona Village, El Columpio and Mya's Teriyaki, and the family also runs Main Street Cafe and Market in Chamberlain. Josh Espinosa told the Mitchell Republic:

"Restaurant-wise, we know what we're doing. I believe we have a really good idea when it comes to building restaurants and bringing attraction, creating good cuisine for the community. But this is outside of our comfort area."

How the Building Is Laid Out

The site covers five city lots. Here is how the Nov. 11 report describes each part of the plan:

Part of the building What's planned
Main Street frontage Four larger retail storefronts, each about 30 feet wide and 40 feet deep, or roughly 1,200 square feet, with two entrances into the courtyard
Back of the courtyard Four to six smaller storefronts with walls that can be adjusted to fit each business
Center of the courtyard An open-air-style market with a central walkway, high ceilings, glass storefronts, trees, plants and gardens, and possibly a water feature and pop-up retail stands
Second floor A restaurant, not yet named, serving breakfast and lunch, with a full-service bar and an open-air patio
Possible third floor Apartments and short-term rentals, which Espinosa hopes the architect's blueprints will include

Espinosa told the paper the courtyard design came from his travels abroad and called it "just another option for more life downtown." Three kinds of businesses have already asked about leasing space: a nail salon, a fast food restaurant and a martial arts studio.

Those prospects would bring back what the address used to be. The old 511 N. Main held a bar, a photo studio, a jewelry counter and a card shop over the years. The plan returns the lot to several separate businesses sharing one front door on Main Street.

What the Restaurant Upstairs Will Serve

The restaurant has no name yet, and it is the piece of the project closest to Josh Espinosa's own background. The Mitchell Republic reports that he planned on a career in international business after college. He then worked in a restaurant's scratch kitchen and found he loved the work. The menu he described follows that experience: French toast, biscuits and gravy, crepes, sandwiches and soups, all made from scratch. "Scratch — It's a lot of labor into it, but gives a really good flavor," he told the paper.

Dinner is planned for later. Espinosa said it would differ from what downtown offers now.

The patio will matter most in a Mitchell winter. Espinosa sees the second-floor patio looking out over downtown and the Corn Palace. The design could include movable walls, an overhang and heaters, so part of the space can be closed in and used during the colder months. The liquor license moved from Justin Thiesse to Israel Espinosa with City Council approval on Aug. 17, 2026, and it stays inactive until the restaurant opens.

The Pieces of the Back 40 That Stay

The building is coming down, but some of what hung inside it is staying. Espinosa is saving its eclectic signs, gear chandeliers, memorabilia and pianos.

Those fixtures belong to the restaurant's later years. Keke Leiferman owned the Back 40, and in May 2018 the Mitchell Republic reported that a taphouse was being added and the target opening was June 1 that year. In December 2024, the paper reported that Leiferman had been gradually moving out while working to sell the building. She planned to keep serving Back 40 food and hosting "some of my little events" on reduced hours until it sold. The sale closed this past January, when Israel Espinosa bought the land and buildings, all five lots, for a stated value of $300,000 according to the warranty deed.

Why the Opening Date Is 2028

Spring 2028 is roughly a year and a half away, and the order of the work explains the wait:

  1. Plans first. In August the blueprints were in their final stages. The November report says demolition will come after the building plans are finished and approved by the city.
  2. Full teardown. "We will tear everything down as we've done with all the other restaurants. We do it the right way," Josh Espinosa said in August.
  3. Financing tools. The project hopes to use the city's landfill fee refund program for rehabilitated properties and plans to seek tax increment financing. When the City Council took up the proposal in January 2026, it was written to reimburse documented landfill costs for developments that have to remove existing structures. Under that draft, applicants would apply before cleanup and finish improvements within 24 months.
  4. Build and open. The building's target opening is spring 2028.

"This has to be done right, layout right, everything right," Espinosa told the Mitchell Republic.

The Building Next Door Already Has Its Rooftop Patio

The Back 40 also ran a second storefront at 505 N. Main, which served as its kitchen. That building is not part of the courtyard project. On Feb. 23, 2026, the Planning Commission approved local roofer Matt Evers' plan for it: a refreshed stucco storefront and roofline, a 14-by-24-foot roof patio, offices inside and storage for contractors. By early July, the Mitchell Republic reported that the front office was ready for furniture and the patio was already in use. Storage, interior finish work and the exterior siding were still in progress then.

If both projects finish, this short stretch of North Main will have two upper-level outdoor spaces next to each other: Evers' roof patio and the Espinosa restaurant's patio looking toward the Corn Palace.

Farther south, developer John Adamo has been working his way down Main Street. In June 2026, the Mitchell Republic counted his historic building at Main Street and Second Avenue as his seventh Main Street renovation. His earlier projects include the former Montgomery Ward building at Fifth Avenue and the Western building at Third Avenue. The former Woolworth building at 300 N. Main St. is one of his as well. The courtyard at 511 N. Main is a different kind of project, a full teardown and new building rather than a restoration, but it adds storefronts to the same street.

Mitchell Realty handles commercial property and development sales across Mitchell, including downtown buildings like those along North Main. If you own a Main Street storefront or want to know what space is available downtown, our brokers can walk you through the options. Contact a Local Expert.

Work With Us

With unparalleled industry knowledge, experience, and local expertise, we're the Mitchell Real Estate experts you've been looking for. Whether you're buying or selling, we can help you get the best deal.

Follow Us on Instagram